I am a person with peeves. I rock a rankle when words I aim to eviscerate from my own vocabulary come up in conversation. One such logjam of letters is should. It’s judgy AF (rich, coming from me, here pronouncing my ruling, I know) and solves nothing. If someone tells me “you should”, I’m all who the fuck are you? and the hackles go up in an instant. Should sets up troublesome expectations escaping the reality of the way things are.
Look up the word in the American Heritage Dictionary, you will see it is “used to express” in the first three definitions, the following things: obligation, duty, probability, expectation, conditionality, and contingency. For the first two, a substitution of will, need, or am going to shirks the equivocation of the dreaded sh. The rest are all has-beens in the maybe-will category of things to do; none are definitive.
The Word About Town
Whenever I hear it from a mouth not mine, I want to share links of why to rid straight away. They say it better than I at articles here, here, and here.
I even saw a political signs entreating “You should vote for …” Yik yech blech, no vote from me, no sirree.
Skip it.
All should does is set up guilt, make us feel angst about something that isn’t happening. Should is irrelevant, it’s time to kick it to the curb. “I’m a member of the church of what’s happening now.” is a favorite statement of a favorite shipmate from my sailor life. It’s time to live according to what is as opposed to what should be.
I posit the question: As yourself what feelings should stirs up. All bad things. Am I wrong?
Some suggestive substitutions:
Instead of: I should be checking things off my list.
Try this: Today I will do one thing on my list.
It will feel so good to check it off. Then you realize how easy it was to do the thing you’d been avoiding, you decide to do two.
Instead of: I should be posting more on my blog.
Try this: I have several unfinished posts, I am going to work on one.
I get it, it’s hard, old habits, y’know? I still should on myself sometimes. It’s work to eschew the shame of should. Once identified, it becomes easier. Life gets lived based on what can happen, what I will to unfold.
Discover more from Midlife Refit
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Have to comment on this – I have no negative associations with that word at all, I think it’s more about the context in which it is used that makes it negative.. Just like “can” – i.e. Can you be more like others? vs I can do it!
“You should find time to xyz” – sure that sounds like it could lead to feelings of guilt/disappointment/overwhelm.. but what about “You should put yourself first” ..? Can’t this word be used to offer solicited advise or support in a positive way?
I would argue that should still implies you are not putting yourself first and can be omitted entirely, why not “Put yourself first”, it’s unequivocal. At this point, it’s a peeve and I hardly ever see it used positively.
I should meditate tonight…
No.
I will meditate tonight
🙂